Read the Cunningham & Associates Blog

Why What You Keep at Exit Is Decided Years Before You Sell

Written by Ryan Foley | Sep 2, 2026, 2:22:10 PM

Most owners think the value of their exit is settled in the negotiation. Find the right buyer, hold the line on the multiple, and win the deal. That's part of it, but the truth is, the value was decided years early and this is why most owners walk away with less than they should.

Your value was being determined years, even decades before. What entity you chose to operate as. When a holding clock started. Whether your ownership was structured to be sold in one taxable event or several. By the time a buyer is at the table, most of those decisions are locked. You are negotiating inside a box that your past self put yourself in.

Thoughtful long-term planning is how you build a bigger box. It doesn't squeeze a better number out of the final conversation. It changes how much of the number you actually keep, and it does so through structures that only work if they are installed years ahead. Here's how that works.

Time is the one input you cannot buy back

Every meaningful exit lever runs on a clock. Tax positions that require a holding period. Ownership transfers that require a runway. Readiness improvements that take years to show up in the financials.

The owner who starts three years out has options for an optimized exit. The owner who starts three months out has a sale. 

Here are two of the most valuable, and the rules around them have recently changed to your benefit.

A tax-free exit is possible, if you plan for it

Section 1202 of the tax code allows owners of C corporation stock to exclude their gain from federal tax when they sell. This is not a deduction, and it is not a deferral to some later year. It is exclusion. Where the gain fits inside the exclusion you have built, the federal tax on that gain is not lowered by a few points. It is zero. Planned early enough and structured correctly, an owner walks away from the sale owing nothing in federal taxes.

For years the rule was all or nothing. You held the stock for at least five years and excluded up to 100 percent of the gain, capped at the greater of 10 million dollars or ten times your basis. Sell early and you got none of it.

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act rewrote that math for stock acquired after July 4, 2025. The exclusion is now tiered. Hold for three years and you can exclude half the gain. Hold for four years and you can exclude three quarters. Hold for five years and you reach the full 100 percent. The per-issuer cap rose from 10 million to 15 million dollars, and the ceiling on the size of a qualifying company rose from 50 million to 75 million in gross assets. Both figures begin adjusting for inflation in 2027.

Read that carefully, because the planning implications are significant.

First, this is a benefit of a C corporation. If you operate as an S corporation, an LLC, or a partnership, you do not have it. Capturing it means restructuring your entity, and that is not a closing-table decision. It is a years-ahead decision.

Second, it runs on a clock. Even the shortest tier requires a three-year hold. You cannot manufacture that hold in the final months before a sale. The owner who structured and started the clock early has a partially or fully tax-free exit available. The owner who waited has a fully taxable one. Same business, same sale price, and on a large gain the difference between them can be the difference between a substantial tax bill, and none.

Third, the older rules still govern stock acquired on or before July 4, 2025, which means the exact position you hold and when you acquired it changes the strategy. This is not a provision you want to discover after the fact. It is one you build toward.

You do not have to sell it all at once

The second lever is the shape of the transaction itself. Most owners assume a single lump-sum sale is the only path to liquidity. It is not always the best one, and for tax purposes it is often the worst.

A structured redemption is one alternative. Instead of selling to an outside buyer in one event, or asking the nest generation to take on debt to buy you out, the company buys back your shares, frequently in stages over several years. Done deliberately, that staging does real work. It can spread your gain across multiple tax years rather than stacking it into one. It can reduce or eliminate taxes and it can let you take meaningful value while you still hold upside in the business.

In a family business, structured redemptions do something further. They fund a departing owner's exit while ownership transitions to the next generation or to a management team, and they can be funded internally or backed by insurance so the liquidity is there when it is needed. Now layer the two levers together. Gift stock to trusts or family members before a sale and the per-issuer exclusion is no longer capped at a single taxpayer's limit. It multiplies across every holder. That is how an owner takes a gain that looked partially taxable and expands the exclusion until it covers all of it. Combine that with a redemption structured to qualify as a sale rather than a dividend, staged to fit inside the exclusion room you have created, and the federal tax on the transaction can be brought to zero by design rather than by luck. That is sophisticated work. It only exists as an option if it is built well ahead of the transaction, which is the entire point.

Value is lost in the years you do nothing

Step back and the pattern is the same one that governs everything about a strong exit. The value you keep is not produced at the negotiating table. It is produced in the years of structuring that came before it.

This is the difference between what your exit could be worth to you and what it will actually be worth, created by structuring, timing, and decisions made or not made long before a buyer appears. Every lever that closes it, the entity choice, the holding clock, the shape of the redemption, the gifting done in advance, runs on a runway you create.

This is the work most advisors are not doing

A broker gets paid when you sell. A CPA files an accurate return, which is a record of what already happened. Neither role is designed to prepare you for a sale and build the structures that determine how much of it you keep. 

If no one in your advisory circle has walked you through your entity structure, your QSBS position, and the shape of your eventual transaction, then no one is planning your exit. They are documenting your present. The distinction is measured in the millions of dollars that stay with you or are lost to taxes.

The good news?  Almost all of it, could still be in your control..

f you want to understand where your entity structure, your QSBS position, and your exit strategy stand while there is still time to shape them, we can walk through it.