Read the Cunningham & Associates Blog

If your tax plan hasn’t changed in years… is it even a plan?

Written by Ryan Foley | Feb 4, 2026 3:06:38 PM

Most business owners don’t choose an outdated, inefficient tax strategy.

It just happens.

You set up your entity. You create a compensation structure. You find a CPA. You file on time. Maybe you add a few deductions. You feel responsible.

Then three years go by.

Revenue changes. The team changes. Your goals change. Your life changes. The law changes.

But your “plan” doesn’t.

And that’s how business owners end up paying more tax than it should, without ever doing anything “wrong.”

Here’s a simple truth:

A tax plan that doesn’t evolve with you isn’t a plan. It’s a habit.

We've created a practical checklist of “change events” that should trigger a strategy reset, so you can stop assuming you’re optimized and start knowing.

Why stale tax plans quietly cost you

A tax strategy is not a one-time setup. It’s a moving target.

Why?

Because your outcomes are shaped by things that evolve and change:

  • Your profit level

  • How you pay yourself

  • Who’s involved (partners, spouse, kids, key employees)

  • Where you do business

  • What you buy (equipment, vehicles, real estate)

  • Your future plans (exit, succession, legacy)

  • The tax laws and deadlines that change the rules

A plan built for your business three years ago is probably misaligned today, even if your returns are accurate.

Accurate filing is not the same as optimized strategy.

The 3-year test (a quick gut-check)

If you’re not sure whether your plan has gone stale, answer these quickly:

  • Have you had a major change in profit?

  • Have you added or lost a partner or key decision-maker?

  • Have you changed states, added a new location, or started selling into new states?

  • Have you bought property, expanded, or taken on significant debt?

  • Have you hired family members or changed who you’re paying?

  • Have you started thinking about selling, succession, or stepping back?

If you answered “yes” to even one, your plan is almost certainly outdated.

The “Change Event” Checklist: triggers that should reset your strategy

Think of these as strategy alarms. When they happen, your tax plan should be re-evaluated, not next year, not “after busy season,” but while you can still act. The sooner you act, the better the outcome.

1) Your profit jumped (or dropped) meaningfully

Trigger: Your net income moved up or down by ~20%+ or crossed a new threshold.

Why it matters: Many strategies only work at certain profit levels. What was “fine” at $150k can be expensive at $500k. What was aggressive at $500k might be risky or pointless at $200k.

Questions to ask:

  • Is my compensation structure still efficient?

  • Should we revisit entity structure or how income is reported?

  • Are we timing income and expenses intentionally—or just reacting?

Common outcome: You’re doing “normal” things that were reasonable before, but now they’re leaving money on the table.

2) You added a partner (or changed ownership)

Trigger: New partner, equity changes, buy-in/buyout talks, profit-sharing changes.

Why it matters: Partnerships create complexity fast—allocations, distributions, basis, guaranteed payments, buy-sell agreements, and future exit terms.

Questions to ask:

  • Does our ownership structure match how value is actually created?

  • Are we clear on what happens if someone exits, becomes disabled, or dies?

  • Is the agreement built to reduce future tax friction, or create it?

Common outcome: Owners focus on “fair,” but not “tax-smart,” and the business pays for it later.

3) You moved states or expanded into a new state

Trigger: You relocated, opened a new location, hired remote employees across state lines, or began selling into new states.

Why it matters: State tax exposure can surprise even smart owners. Payroll, sales, and “nexus” rules can trigger filing requirements and create double-tax headaches.

Questions to ask:

  • Do we know where we have filing obligations?

  • Are we tracking the right things (payroll location, sales, contractors)?

  • Are we exposed to penalties simply because we didn’t know?

Common outcome: State tax issues don’t show up until they’re expensive.

4) You bought real estate (or are thinking about it)

Trigger: Purchasing a building, buying a rental, moving the business into owned property, or planning a lease-to-own.

Why it matters: Real estate affects depreciation, entity structure, liability planning, rent strategy, and future sale taxes.

Questions to ask:

  • Should the property be held in a separate entity?

  • Is there a clean rent strategy between business and property entity?

  • Are we planning for the long-term tax impact (not just this year’s write-offs)?

Common outcome: The purchase is done “because it felt right,” but the structure is decided too late.

5) You made a big equipment/vehicle purchase

Trigger: Large capital purchases, fleet expansion, new machinery, or vehicles used for the business.

Why it matters: Timing, classification, and documentation can dramatically change outcomes. Also, vehicle rules are one of the most common audit pain points for owners.

Questions to ask:

  • Should we buy or lease (and why)?

  • Are we tracking usage correctly and defensibly?

  • Are we planning purchases strategically—or buying based on cash flow only?

Common outcome: You get some deductions, but you miss the best timing and documentation, and sometimes create future tax problems.

6) You hired family members (or started paying your spouse)

Trigger: Bringing kids into payroll, paying a spouse, shifting responsibilities inside the family.

Why it matters: Done right, this can be legitimate and powerful. Done loosely, it can become risky and messy.

Questions to ask:

  • Are the roles real, documented, and paid reasonably?

  • Are we using the right structure and payroll rules?

  • Are we coordinating this with long-term family wealth and estate goals?

Common outcome: Owners either avoid this entirely (missing opportunity) or do it casually (creating risk).

7) You changed how you pay yourself

Trigger: Adjusting salary/distributions, changing draw strategy, new bonus approach, or shifting benefits.

Why it matters: Owner comp is one of the biggest levers in tax planning, and one of the most misunderstood. What you pay yourself impacts payroll taxes, deductions, retirement options, and overall planning flexibility.

Questions to ask:

  • Is my compensation aligned with profit and risk tolerance?

  • Does it support my retirement and long-term goals?

  • Would a third party agree this structure is reasonable?

Common outcome: Owners set comp once and never touch it again, even when the business doubles.

8) You’re considering a sale (even “someday”)

Trigger: You’ve thought about selling in the next 2–5 years, received interest, or you’re building toward an exit.

Why it matters: The biggest tax decisions around a sale often happen before you’re ready to sell. Structure, cleanup, documentation, and planning take time. Not to mention the One Big Beautiful Act has made it possible to sell your business and pay ZERO taxes, with the right planning.

Questions to ask:

  • If I sold next year, what would my tax bill look like?

  • Is my entity structure helping or hurting a future deal?

  • Are we building value in a way that’s transferable and defensible?

Common outcome: Owners wait until a buyer appears, and then discover their “tax plan” doesn’t support an exit.

9) You started thinking about estate planning in a serious way

Trigger: Kids getting older, health changes, net worth growth, or realizing the business is the main asset.

Why it matters: Business owners need estate plans that address control, continuity, liquidity, and decision-making, not just a basic will.

Questions to ask:

  • If something happened to me, who controls the business tomorrow?

  • Does my estate plan work with my business agreements?

  • Are my tax, business, and estate strategies working together, or separately?

Common outcome: The legal documents exist, but the plan is incomplete.

10) Tax law changes made you uneasy (or you ignored them)

Trigger: New legislation, expiring provisions, shifting credits/deductions, changing enforcement priorities. For example, the One Big Beautiful Bill is the single most impact tax law change in recent history.

Why it matters: Tax laws change—sometimes in ways that create opportunity, sometimes in ways that create risk. Either way, a static strategy becomes guesswork.

Questions to ask:

  • Did any recent changes affect my entity, deductions, payroll strategy, or timing?

  • Are we being proactive, or just reacting at filing time?

  • Is my advisor bringing options, or just reporting outcomes?

Common outcome: Owners assume “my CPA would tell me,” but no one is accountable for forward-looking strategy unless you build it into the relationship.

What a strategy reset actually looks like (it’s simpler than you think)

A reset isn’t a dramatic overhaul. It’s a structured review that answers:

  1. What changed? (profit, ownership, location, goals, timeline)

  2. What’s the current plan? (entity, comp, deductions, retirement, estate alignment)

  3. What’s no longer true? (assumptions from 3 years ago)

  4. What are the best levers now? (the “few moves” that matter most)

  5. What’s the action plan? (who does what, by when, with documentation)

The goal isn’t complexity.

The goal is alignment: tax strategy that supports your business strategy and your life strategy.

The easiest next step: a simple self-audit

If you want a quick way to put this into motion, do this:

Write down:

  • Your business goals for the next 12 months

  • Your personal goals for the next 3–5 years

  • The biggest change event you’ve had recently

Then ask one question:

“Is our tax strategy built for where we’re going—or where we’ve been?”

If you can’t answer clearly, you don’t have a plan. You have momentum.

Bottom line

If your tax plan hasn’t changed in three years, one of two things is true:

  1. Your business hasn’t meaningfully changed (rare), or

  2. Your plan is outdated (common)

Business owners don’t need more tax “tips.”

They need a strategy that evolves, because their business and goals do.

Want help pressure-testing your plan?

If you’ve had any of the change events above, it may be time for a strategy review, especially before the year gets away from you.

A simple review can uncover:

  • missed savings opportunities,

  • hidden risk,

  • and whether your tax moves match your short- and long-term goals.

We can help, we will execute a no-cost, no-obligation tax strategy review. Two outcomes, we confirm you're in good shape or we identify significant gaps and areas for substantial saving. Win - win.

Set up a time to talk with our team.